Asks Barbara Crook of Palestinian Media Watch, in the Ottawa Citizen:
The
world reacted with outrage at the speech by Iranian President Mahmoud
Ahmadinejad at the Durban Review Conference on Racism in Geneva.
European countries stormed out of his talk and released an array of
statements condemning his words.
But the real problem is not that
an Ahmadinejad exists, or that he proudly and vociferously spews hatred
against Jews and blames Zionism for the world's evils. The problem is
that his views are anything but unique in the Muslim world.
Tragically,
it seems that western leaders are using Ahmadinejad as their radical
Islamic whipping boy in order to content themselves that they are doing
all they can to fight growing radical Islamic racism, its calls for a
world without Israel and genocide of Jews, and its espousal of
Holocaust denial.
In reality, the strong media and government
reactions to Ahmadinejad's hate promotion serve only to highlight their
hypocrisy in ignoring the same ideology when it's expressed by Arab
leaders who have succeeded in making the western world's list of "good
guys."
Saudi King Abdullah -- whom president George W. Bush
kissed and to whom President Barack Obama bowed earlier this month --
has blamed Israel for terror attacks in Saudi Arabia: "We can be
certain that Zionism is behind everything ... I don't say 100 per cent,
but 95 per cent." (Saudi 1 Television, May 2, 2004)
Grade 9
children in Saudi Arabia are taught that "the hour (of judgment) will
not come until the Muslims fight the Jews and kill them, until the Jew
hides behind rocks and trees, until the rocks or the trees say, 'O
Muslim! O servant of God! There is a Jew behind me. Come and kill him!"
Earlier
this year, the head of the Department of Islamic Studies at Saud
University pronounced that "Jews are the enemies of Allah." Dr. Walid
Al-Rashudi also prayed for the extermination of all Jews: "Kill them
one by one and don't leave even one." (Al-Aqsa (Hamas) TV, Jan. 12,
2009)
It is the very existence of the Jews, not their actions or
even their Zionism, that fuels the rhetoric of many Islamic political
and religious leaders.
"If the Jews left Palestine to us, would
we start loving them? Of course not ... They are enemies not because
they occupied Palestine. They would have been enemies even if they did
not occupy a thing," said Egyptian cleric Muhammad Hussein Ya'qoub.
"... You must believe that we will fight, defeat, and annihilate them,
until not a single Jew remains on the face of the Earth." (Al-Rahma TV
(Egypt), Jan. 17, 2009)
Is this any different from Ahmadinejad's calls for a world without Israel?
And
look at Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbas, depicted by the
West as a moderate to whom Israel is supposed to offer statehood. But
the TV channel directly controlled by Abbas's office regularly runs
educational programs to teach Palestinian adults and children alike
that there is no state called Israel, and that all Israel's land is
actually "occupied Palestine."
Palestinian children are taught
that Israeli cities throughout the entire country -- from Haifa in the
North, to Jaffa (part of Tel Aviv), to Eilat in the south, are all
actually Palestinian cities. Videos feature songs about a "Palestine"
that erases Israel and a future when the Israeli cities Jaffa and Haifa
will be "liberated."
Hamas, which has convinced many western
leaders and journalists that it spends more time building schools than
bombing civilians, broadcast a sermon earlier this month depicting the
Jews as enemies of humanity, inherently evil, seeking to rule the world
and a dangerous threat to Muslims: "The time will come, by Allah's
will, when their property will be destroyed and their children will be
exterminated, and no Jew or Zionist will be left on the face of this
earth." (Al-Aqsa (Hamas) TV, April 3, 2009)
Why is Ahmadinejad's
Holocaust denial so passionately denounced when Palestinian Holocaust
denial is so utterly ignored? Hamas TV broadcast a special documentary
last year, explaining that the Holocaust was a Zionist scheme to rid
the world of elderly and handicapped, and to gain world sympathy.
Fatah's PA TV broadcast a children's program that said explicitly that
Israel burned Palestinians in ovens.
So why is Abbas presented as
a peace partner, Egypt as a peace broker and Abdullah as a friend of
the West? Why does the world not react with outrage to calls for
"extermination" of Jews from anyone other than Ahmadinejad?
If
the West is serious about peace, all hatred must be condemned. And we
must recognize that the real enemies of peace are not only the
Ahmadinejads of the world, but the "friends" who have mastered the
doublespeak of calling for peace in English while inciting hatred in
Arabic.
Barbara Crook, who lives in Ottawa, is associate director
and North American representative of Palestinian Media Watch,
www.pmw.org